I come from a country where backgammon is part of our culture, every one knows how to play, every one spent countless thousands of hours playing this game. The fact is, that particularly with this (the "international" variant of backgammon) there is little strategic thought for experienced players. There are only so many "set pieces" and once you're experienced you have automatic responses for practically all situations. The game is govererned by the roll of the dice, the rest is automatic (there are 2 other variants of backgammon played in Greece which have a significantly higher element of strategic play, but are practically unknown anywhere else sadly). Why am i mentioning this? Well, as others have mentioned, it's impossible to not feel like you've been cheated continuously by this program. The ratio with which the app wins seems like 4-5:1. When it's winning, it reliably rolls doubles 4-5 times more frequently than the human player, and when the latter rolls 5's or 6's, you can bet that it will be detrimental. I've seen comments amongst the suspiciously large amount of 5 star ratings that follow each detrimental commentary, that people who say this "have not logged enough hours on the analog version" or something similar. Well, I've "logged" well over 20,000 misspent hours on the real version of this game, and can assure you that even if you're on a losing streak playing against a really lucky person, it's never like this on a continuous basis. It's very clear that even if the program doesn't cheat, it has a very flawed dice rolling system. In most other respects, the program is polished and pleasant, and for inexperienced players, this will be a nice program. Most others won't want to bother in the long term (i tried about 30 matches in demo mode, and will clearly not be paying for this in it's current form). One suggestion for the author (apart from sorting out the dice rolling problem) is considering integrating the 2 other variants played widely in Greece. While these are not well known in other countries, they do provide significantly higher degree of strategic challenge. The 3 variants are usually played in rotation to provide variety and will undoubtedly increase the longevity of the app. |